Optimist
  • News
  • Sports
  • Opinion
    • Columns
    • Editorials
    • Letters to the Editor
  • Features
    • Book Review
  • Multimedia
    • Photo Galleries
    • Videos
  • Podcasts
    • Optimist Overtime
    • Top of the Key
  • Police Log
  • Print Edition
  • Projects
  • About
    • Advertise
    • Policies
    • Staff Contacts
    • Jobs
You are here: Home / Opinion / Letters to the Editor / Is free speech worth the challenges

Is free speech worth the challenges

November 8, 2018 by Lauren Franco

-by David Kneip, associate professor of Bible.

An oft-quoted saying with regard to free speech goes something like this: “I disapprove of what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it.”  Often mis-attributed to the 18th-century French philosopher known as Voltaire, the quote certainly reflects the budding “freedom” movement of that era, which blossomed strongly with events like the American Revolution and texts like the Bill of Rights.

To be sure, this statement is wholly modern—it reflects modern sensibilities—but it is not particularly Christian.  I write this because ACU’s chapter of the Young Americans for Freedom has recently erected a “wall” on campus that they intend to tear down as a celebration of Veteran’s Day and a commemoration of the fall of the Berlin Wall in 1989.  

However, per YAF’s instructions, the ACU chapter has inscribed various things on their wall that they claim to be “ways in which their freedoms are being infringed upon.”  As of Thursday afternoon, the phrases mirror those found at the YAF website: “microaggressions,” “safe spaces,” and “trigger warnings.” Presumably, these phrases are meant to reflect concerns expressed by many cultural observers about a perceived “fragility” on the part of college students; see, as just one example, George F. Will’s September 12 column in the Washington Post.

Unfortunately, critiques of these ideas, and of the policies and movements that encourage us to be mindful of them, often degenerate into attacks on the individuals who might ask us to be mindful of them, or whom they might benefit.  And as a university, this is where things get difficult. As an educational institution, we seek both to challenge and to care for one another, and sometimes those aims clash with one another.

On the one hand, it is critical to our mission for learners to be exposed to ideas that challenge them.  We know that the process of “doing difficult things” helps us learn in ways that rote repetition of simple tasks does not.  We want to reason well, and one way to build cognitive “muscle” comes from lifting difficult intellectual and conceptual weight.  To these ends, free speech is a critical component, as we must be able to hear views with which we disagree.

However, in many cases, we want to learn, and yet we face difficulties that are not of our own making and over which we have little to no power.  Just to name a few: we may come from families marked by divorce or addiction; we may have been abused, neglected, or otherwise traumatized; we may have experienced significant losses in the recent or distant past.  As we learn, we may become overwhelmed—not through hot-button topics or social issues, but rather because a course’s subject matter hits close to home, through discussing child abuse in a social-work class, grief in a psychology class, or the exploitation of workers in a business class.  Learners such as these may benefit from institutional policies that express care for students.

And this is where our Christian identity is crucial.  Free speech is an American virtue, but it is not necessarily a Christian one.  The letter of James specifically teaches us to be “quick to listen and slow to speak” (1:19).  Paul’s letter to the Romans includes instructions to “honor one another above yourselves,” to “bless and not curse” those with whom we disagree, and to work hard to live at peace with everyone (12:9, 14, 18).  Jesus himself blesses the merciful and the peacemakers (Matthew 5:7, 9).

As a result, on the principles of free speech, I do not reject the building of our “wall”; the end of World War I (the source of our Veteran’s Day celebration) and the end of Russian Communism are events celebrated by many Americans.  But I would encourage the builders of that wall (and all of us) to examine ourselves. If we are followers of Christ, the one who had everything but gave it up for us and for our salvation (Philippians 2:5-11), is it really best to demand our own rights of free speech?  Should we really build a wall, write phrases on it that allude to our brothers and sisters, and literally break it down with hammers? How is that possibly hospitable? As Paul says regarding disputes among Christians, “Why not rather be wronged? Why not rather be cheated?” (1 Corinthians 6:7).

To my brothers and sisters who feel that their speech has been infringed by movements in higher education that call us to care for one another: let’s talk—conversation is welcome here.  And to my brothers and sisters who are sometimes overwhelmed by life (that’s most of us, I daresay), who are sometimes overlooked, who are ignored, and who are otherwise disadvantaged by those of us in places of cultural superiority: you are welcome here.  Let’s keep talking.

Filed Under: Letters to the Editor

Other Opinion:

  • Analyzing the Capitol riots through both lenses

  • To achieve unity, we need to start listening

  • Quality online education requires lecturing and better communication

Avatar

About Lauren Franco

My name is Lauren and I'm the Editor in Chief of the Optimist this year. I'm an avid fan of romantic comedies, the First Amendment and national parks. More than anything, I'm passionate about storytelling via photographs, and love getting to know the heart of people through my lens.

You are here: Home / Opinion / Letters to the Editor / Is free speech worth the challenges

Other Opinion:

  • Analyzing the Capitol riots through both lenses

  • To achieve unity, we need to start listening

  • Quality online education requires lecturing and better communication

Follow us online

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Optimist on Twitter

acuoptimistThe Optimist@acuoptimist·
4h

"We need to start taking steps toward understanding each other no matter how repulsed we may be initially." Read more from Managing Editor Dillon Daniel below:
https://acuoptimist.com/2021/01/to-achieve-unity-we-need-to-start-listening/

Reply on Twitter 1351990382385479682Retweet on Twitter 1351990382385479682Like on Twitter 13519903823854796822Twitter 1351990382385479682
acuoptimistThe Optimist@acuoptimist·
19 Jan

"Lack of interaction — whether online or in-person — leads to lack of connections between professors and students." Read more from Guest Columnist Morgen Maltby below:
https://acuoptimist.com/2021/01/quality-online-education-requires-lecturing-and-better-communication/

Reply on Twitter 1351590244966150146Retweet on Twitter 1351590244966150146Like on Twitter 13515902449661501462Twitter 1351590244966150146

Optimist on Facebook

The Optimist

4 hours ago

The Optimist
"We need to start taking steps toward understanding each other no matter how repulsed we may be initially." Read more from Managing Editor Dillon Daniel below: ...

To achieve unity, we need to start listening - Optimist

acuoptimist.com

There is no question that the current climate among Americans is tense and, as the Capitol Hill and 2020 riots show, even hostile. Although these behaviors have always been present, it seems that the last decade has seen an increase in tribal tendencies. We cling to the ankles of our political candi...
View on Facebook
· Share

Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Linked In Share by Email

The Optimist

1 day ago

The Optimist
"Lack of interaction — whether online or in-person — leads to lack of connections between professors and students." Read more from Guest Columnist Morgen Maltby below: ...

Quality online education requires lecturing and better communication - Optimist

acuoptimist.com

With the university handling new forms of teaching in light of COVID-19, many classes have been moved to an online format due to safety for the professors and students. Because of this unexpected transition, fewer guidelines were placed on class procedures. Some professors chose to have weekly Zoom....
View on Facebook
· Share

Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Linked In Share by Email

Videos

Praise Day Fridays return to campus

Video by Allie Jones. https://youtu.be/4F0D1oNzGjM   ... [Read More…]

  • Optimist Newscast – Nov. 5, 2020
  • ACUTV, Optimist preparing for live election show
  • Earliest snowfall recorded in Abilene

Latest Photos

  • Home
  • Weekly Ads
  • Classifieds

© 2021 ACU Optimist · All Rights Reserved